3 Tips for Building Massive Sales Credibility (When You Have None)

Recently, I was chatting with a sales leader who mentioned his reps were having trouble generating enough pipeline (sound familiar?).

What’s the issue?” I asked. “Do your reps not have enough leads?

No,” he said, “they have lots of accounts to call on, but they’re just not calling on enough key stakeholders.

Why?” I asked again. “Do they not know how to get customers on the phone?

No,” he continued, “I think it’s just that a lot of my reps are new to the team and they’re not confident calling high-level customer executives and talking to them about their business.”

And why’s that?” I asked. (I’m a fan of the 5 Why’s methodology.)

Because they feel they don’t have the stories and insights yet. They feel they lack credibility and won’t be able to add value to the conversation. They’re afraid.

And there lies the root of the problem.

Most modern buyer-seller relationships suffer from experience asymmetry. Meaning most sales reps have rarely held the roles of the customers they are calling on. They may not understand what it’s actually like to be in their shoes and that lack of perceived credibility manifests as fear (and even worse, lack of conviction – a critical skill in pipeline development). Unfortunately, that fear can be a big impediment to sales productivity, especially for new, younger, or inexperienced sales reps. And the concern is indeed a real one.

Suppose you had a medical condition that required you to see a specialist. When you walk into the doctor’s office to share your concern, ideally, you want them to take one look at you, say they’ve seen what you have a thousand times before, and confidently recommend a course of treatment to get you well. On the other hand, you’re less likely to value the interaction with a less-experienced but well-intentioned, new physician stumbling through a diagnosis.

So how do you infuse your sales reps with the confidence and credibility they need to make the big calls and drive the pipeline you expect?

Here are 3 simple tips:

1. Write your stories down

Chances are, if you’ve been in business even for a little while, you have some happy customers — customers for whom your solution has delivered value. These customer stories are your greatest source of credibility in a sales cycle, yet you’d be surprised how rarely these stories are written down or memorialized in the form of case studies, white papers, or testimonial videos. If you want your reps to be credible, they need to know these stories intimately.

Don’t just write them down and make sure they read them; take them to task! Have them rattle their stories off to you in a poised, confident, storytelling manner. Have them be very clear about the value realized and the lessons both your organization and the customer learned along the way. The better they are at telling these stories, the more credible they’ll be, the more value they’ll add to the customer, and the more calls they’ll make to high-level stakeholders.

2. Remember who the cred belongs to

As I talk about in Chapter 6 of my book (Page 176: How to Architect Your Discovery Conversations for Maximum Success), if you are new to sales, new to your company, young, or otherwise less experienced, chances are you have little personal credibility with your customers. That’s why saying things like “What I’ve found is… ” or “I think…” carry little weight (I call this the “I-phrasing” trap). Unless you’re Oprah or Bill Gates, no one cares what YOU think!

On the other hand, your customers and the collective experience of your organization carry much more weight and credibility. After all, the stories of success and value are rooted in those experiences. So how do you shift the burden of credibility? Easy. Phrase your talk track in the context of the people to whom the credit belongs.

For example:

  • Our customers have consistently found that…
  • “What we’ve seen time and time again is…
  • “There have been a number of customers who recently made the switch from Competitor A to us and what they told us was…”
  • “If you look at the reviews of both products on third-party sites like G2 and TrustRadius, one of the trends you’ll notice is…”
  • “Gartner just released their latest magic quadrant report for our space and what they called out was…”

While this concept seems simple, it requires practice. We’re so used to sharing our personal perspectives that phrasing stories in the context of another’s experience is something you need to get in the habit of doing in customer-facing situations.

Bonus video: How To Speak with Credibility When You Have None!

Bonus video: How To Talk about Your Competition.


3. Cultivate a challenger mentality

I’ve always believed that the best Salespeople should know more about the latest trends and insights in their field than their customers do. Whether we’re looking to buy a new suit, a car, or a piece of technology, most of us looking to buy a product or service rely on the expertise of a salesperson to help guide our purchase. That’s why, when professional credibility is a blocker to sales, it helps to remind your team that they (with the collective wisdom of your customers and the organization behind them) are indeed experts!

If you’re selling a marketing automation solution, for example, ask yourself how many times your customer has purchased a solution like yours versus how many of them you and your organization have sold. I’m willing to bet the advantage sits squarely on your side. Giving your team this perspective will give them the mojo they need to connect with confidence and conviction.

As sales professionals, our goal should always be to add value to the customer experience. For both new and experienced sales reps being held back by fears of credibility and the inability to add that value, these few simple tips should get you well on your way!


David’s article originally appeared on the Entrepreneur.com

Subscribe for Cerebral Selling content updates and tips!

We promise never to send you junk or share your email! Just helpful sales insights.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *